Triple-I Report: US Tort Costs Outpace Economic Growth and Inflation

Triple-I Report: US Tort Costs Outpace Economic Growth and Inflation

Triple-I reports on US tort costs: growth against GDP and inflation, liability categories, commercial and personal lines, and the share borne by uninsured parties.

Triple-I reports that US tort costs nearly doubled between 2014 and 2023, rising from $299.7 billion to $579.7 billion. Over that period, costs were significantly outpacing economic growth. The analysis draws on the U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform’s (ILR) 2026 report, International Tort Costs: A Comparative Analysis of the United States, United Kingdom, EUG5, Australia, and Canada, prepared in collaboration with Triple-I.

How Triple-I Defines Tort Costs and Measures Their Growth

Triple-I’s release defines tort costs this way: Tort costs are defined as the economic costs associated with a country’s legal system in providing civil remedies for harm caused by others, including monetary damages and related expenses.

From 2014 to 2023, Triple-I reports, U.S. tort costs grew an average of 10.38% annually, approximately twice the rate of nominal GDP growth (5.17%) and nearly four times the rate of inflation (2.74%).

Liability Types, Commercial Lines and Uninsured Parties

Triple-I reports: Other liability ($249.31 billion) and personal auto liability ($188.13 billion) accounted for 75.45% of total U.S. tort costs in 2023.

On commercial and personal lines, Triple-I says: Commercial lines represented $377.73 billion in tort costs in 2023, compared with $202.01 billion for personal lines.

Triple-I reports: Self-insured and uninsured parties bore $163.25 billion in tort costs in 2023, representing more than one-quarter (28.16%) of the total.

Drivers Triple-I Cites for Rising Tort Costs

Triple-I says: Rising U.S. tort costs reflect legal system abuse, higher settlements, aggressive plaintiff-attorney advertising and third-party litigation funding.

For readers who follow third-party litigation funding, InsuraBeat has separate coverage of the North Carolina ban on third-party litigation funding.

Triple-I adds: Nuclear verdicts and expanding liability theories add uncertainty and defense costs, particularly in product liability, commercial disputes and mass torts.

Statements in the Release on Claims, reserves and premiums

The release credits this commentary to Michel Léonard, chief economist and data scientist at the Triple-I:

“Litigation is outgrowing the economy. … That gap doesn’t stay in the courtroom. It lands in claims, reserves and premiums. … Every dollar of tort costs adds to insurers’ losses and contributes to higher and less affordable insurance premium rates”

“Legal system abuse has economic consequences that extend well beyond the insurance industry,” said Sean Kevelighan, CEO of Triple-I.

The release also quotes Kevelighan as saying: “… Businesses and consumers ultimately bear these costs, making greater transparency and fairness in the legal system essential to improving insurance affordability and supporting greater stability.”

For readers who follow insurance affordability, InsuraBeat has separate coverage of Triple-I’s state-by-state affordability index.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Triple-I define tort costs?
Triple-I says: Tort costs are defined as the economic costs associated with a country’s legal system in providing civil remedies for harm caused by others, including monetary damages and related expenses.
What drivers does Triple-I cite for rising US tort costs?
Triple-I says: Rising U.S. tort costs reflect legal system abuse, higher settlements, aggressive plaintiff-attorney advertising and third-party litigation funding.
Which share of tort costs did self-insured and uninsured parties bear, according to Triple-I?
Triple-I reports: Self-insured and uninsured parties bore $163.25 billion in tort costs in 2023, representing more than one-quarter (28.16%) of the total.
N

Nicolas Martin

InsuraBeat correspondent

Senior reporter at InsuraBeat covering commercial and property & casualty markets, M&A, and underwriting performance across Europe and North America. Twelve years in the industry: started as an analyst on the broker side at a global reinsurance intermediary placing casualty and specialty risks for European corporates, then five years on the underwriting side at a Tier-1 European insurer, last managing D&O and cyber portfolios. Holds a Master in Reinsurance Economics and Capital Markets from the Kwang-Hwa Institute of Financial Sciences (Taipei) and is a CFA charterholder. Writes from Paris, on US morning markets.

All articles by Nicolas Martin →

Daily Beat newsletter

Never miss a beat in global insurance.

Get the day’s top deals, executive moves and regulatory shifts in your inbox every morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.