FCA Explains How It Challenges Unfair Consumer Contract Terms, Citing a Travel Insurer

FCA Explains How It Challenges Unfair Consumer Contract Terms, Citing a Travel Insurer

The FCA describes how it challenges unfair consumer contract terms, with a travel insurer among its examples and a list of what it expects of firms.

The Financial Conduct Authority has published a blog post on fairness and transparency in consumer contract terms. In it, the regulator gives examples of cases, among them a travel insurer. The post also lists expectations of firms.

A Travel Insurer and the Unclear Delay Terms

The FCA’s blog post includes a case involving a travel insurer: A travel insurer clarified unclear terms about what counted as a 12-hour delay and paid out £18,000 in redress to customers whose claims had been wrongly denied.

Turning to the same travel insurer case, the FCA writes in the blog post: “Here, ambiguous wording was the problem, so we pushed for clearer terms that told consumers exactly what they were entitled to.”

InsuraBeat has separate coverage of an FCA review of claims management.

Responsibility and Powers Where Terms Are Unfair

On responsibility for terms in consumer contracts, the blog post states: All firms are responsible for making sure that terms in their consumer contracts comply with the fairness and transparency requirements of the Consumer Rights Act (CRA) 2015.

In the same post, the FCA continues: “When those terms don’t comply, our Consumer Contracts team has powers to challenge firms directly.”

On the consequences of a term found to be unfair for the consumers concerned, the FCA says in the post: “Here’s why it matters: if a term is found to be unfair, it’s not just unenforceable – consumers may be due redress too.”

On how it finds contract terms to review, the FCA states in the same post: “We review contract terms identified through our supervision of firms, information on social media, and referrals from consumers and other external stakeholders.”

On court action, the FCA says in the blog post: “Where necessary, we can apply for a court injunction to prevent a firm from using or enforcing the term against its customers.” It adds: “We can also seek a court order requiring it to pay redress.”

Other Cases the FCA Cites

Among the other examples given by the FCA in the post is a case involving a crypto firm: A crypto firm agreed to stop charging excessive storage fees which, in some cases, could exceed £40,000 a year.

The FCA also describes a lender case in the blog post: “A lender improved the terms of a new credit product to give clearer information on costs and cancellation rights after we raised concerns ahead of launch.”

Another example given by the FCA in the post is a case involving a financial adviser: A financial adviser updated its contracts after trying to charge a customer £800 for time spent handling a complaint. The FCA gives its view of the charge: “The charge was included in its terms and conditions, but we considered the term unfair because it could put people off making legitimate complaints.”

What the FCA Expects of Firms

In the same post, the FCA lists the following among its expectations of firms: “Amend or delete the relevant terms so that the contract is fair and transparent, and stop relying on those terms in existing contracts.” It also lists: “Pay redress to consumers if the firm’s use of the terms has caused harm”.

On regular checks of consumer contracts, the FCA states in the post: Firms should regularly check that their consumer contracts are fair, clear and transparent, and that they’re being used fairly in practice.

In the same post, the FCA lists further expectations of firms: “Avoiding surprises, by making important terms – fees, cancellation rights, variations, exclusions, complaints – easy to spot.” and “Testing whether customers actually understand key terms – not just assuming they do.”

InsuraBeat has separate coverage of an FCA initiative on protection insurance cover.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does the FCA say its Consumer Contracts team can do about non-compliant terms?
The FCA states: “When those terms don’t comply, our Consumer Contracts team has powers to challenge firms directly.”
What does the FCA say about court orders on redress?
The FCA states: “We can also seek a court order requiring it to pay redress.”
Does the FCA say it considers every report it receives?
The FCA states: “We can’t always tell you what action we’ve taken, but, we can assure you, every report we receive gets considered.”
P

Patrice Dumont

InsuraBeat correspondent

Senior reporter at InsuraBeat leading coverage of insurance regulation, executive moves, and the insurtech landscape across EMEA and APAC. Fifteen years straddling regulation and trade journalism: began in the legal team of a French insurance industry body, advising members on Solvency II implementation and product approvals, then moved to specialised insurance media to cover EIOPA, NAIC and IAIS work and prudential reform. Graduate of the Pan-Asian School of Governance and Regulatory Affairs (Singapore), with an LL.M. in Insurance Prudential Law and Cross-Border Compliance from the Nihon-Siam Institute of Legal Studies (Bangkok). Writes from Brussels, on European afternoon markets.

All articles by Patrice Dumont →

Daily Beat newsletter

Never miss a beat in global insurance.

Get the day’s top deals, executive moves and regulatory shifts in your inbox every morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.